SEC Whistleblower Law – McEldrew Young, whistleblower law.#Whistleblower #law

Posted On May 14 2018 by

SEC Whistleblower Law

In 2010, Congress enacted the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. Part of this reform package provided for the creation of Whistleblower Reward Programs through both the Securities Exchange Commission (“SEC”) and the Commodities Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”).

The SEC and CFTC Whistleblower Programs provide monetary incentives for persons who voluntarily provide original information about possible violations of the Federal Securities Laws or Commodity Exchange Act that result in an order of monetary sanctions exceeding $1 million dollars. Original information is information derived from independent knowledge that is not publicly available. Information may be publicly available if it contains independent analysis and is not already known by the SEC or CFTC.

The Reward

The SEC and CFTC Whistleblower Programs provide financial rewards to whistleblowers who properly report covered fraudulent misconduct, whereby such reports lead to a civil recovery on the part of the respective government agency. A whistleblower who reports ANY securities law violations will receive a reward if the SEC and any other government authorities recover monies. Additionally, a whistleblower will receive 10 percent to 30 percent of the monies the SEC and other government authorities collect based on the whistleblower’s information if more than $1 million is collected. The percentage of the reward is set at the discretion of the SEC taking into consideration the following:

  • The significance of the information provided
  • The assistance provided by the whistleblower and the whistleblower’s attorney
  • The programmatic interest of the Commission in deterring violations of the securities law
  • Additional relevant factors the Commission may establish by rule or regulation

Our SEC whistleblower attorneys regularly evaluate whether individuals are eligible for rewards under the program and whether they have sufficient evidence to make a report worth filing. Contact us for a free, confidential consultation if you are considering submitting information.

What types of information will the SEC be interested in?

Every month, the SEC posts a Notice of Covered Action for cases resulting in a monetary recovery of more than $1 million. We examined the postings for the past year to determine what types of cases the SEC has pursued in the past. This is by no means an exclusive list and there are certainly types of information which will produce rewards for whistleblowers that we have not listed here. However, it does cover a wide range of misconduct and serves as an excellent representation of the scope of cases the SEC has pursued recently.

Companies manipulating accounting standards and data are perennially a target of SEC enforcement actions. The misstatement of revenues, expenses or asset valuations in order to mislead investors, smooth earnings fluctuations or meet analyst estimates will be carefully examined. This includes improper accounting adjustments in violation of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. They are also liable for failure to maintain sufficient internal accounting controls to prevent issues in their financial statements.

Misconduct by independent auditors is also on the radar of the SEC. They are interested in learning about auditors that fail to conduct audits in accordance with Public Company Accounting Oversight Board Standards, especially if they result in the dissemination of materially false and misleading information. They are also interested in accounting firms acting as an independent auditor while performing non-audit services for the same client.

The SEC has prosecuted both individuals trading on inside information and individuals tipping others to material, nonpublic information who then trade. Suspicious transactions such as the purchase of call options in close proximity to earnings or merger announcements may garner close scrutiny.

The SEC has also pursued successful enforcement actions against high-level corporate executives or officers who fail to follow or attempt to circumvent rules regarding stock ownership disclosure and trade reporting. Insiders and those with large ownership positions have special reporting requirements when they conduct stock transactions.

Trading Price Manipulation

Market manipulation is a classic violation of securities laws. Unscrupulous individuals may artificially increase the price or volume of a stock in order to attract other investors. These schemes are sometimes combined with a form of microcap stock fraud where a party issues false and misleading press releases and statements to investors to pump and dump the stock.

Market manipulation does not have to involve the actual execution of orders. The transmission of orders that the trader does not intend to have executed in order to influence the market through layering or spoofing is also prohibited. In other cases, traders have used limit orders to influence mark-to-market accounting in order to mask investment losses.

Misrepresentations to Investors: Shareholder Fraud and Investment Solicitation Problems

Material misrepresentations to investors are taken seriously by the SEC. Failure to disclose material information about the company, including revenues, liabilities, assets and corporate management, are all a major problem. This is particularly true in connection with a security offering. Manipulation of financial statements through mark-to-market pricing or improper accounting adjustments are also an area where the SEC tends to protect shareholder investments.

Similarly, misappropriation of investor funds for personal or business expenses is a common area of enforcement. There cannot be misrepresentations regarding the intended use of funds from an offering or the manner in which client accounts will be invested.

The SEC has been especially diligent regarding ponzi schemes following the Bernie Madoff debacle. Typically, they involve promises of extraordinary or guaranteed results while the individuals operating it pay early investors with money obtained from subsequent investors.

There are many other types of fraud against shareholders which the SEC will pursue. Among the worst offenses are corporations and individuals selling fictitious securities or bank instruments to investors.

There s a widespread investigation of private equity firms concerning the fees and expenses they charge clients. In a 2014 speech, Andrew Bowden indicated that there are disclosure problems regarding the billing of fees and expenses to investors which are separate and distinct from the firm s management fees.

The disclosure of weaknesses in cyber security and data loss due to hacking is a relatively new area for securities law but we expect that there will be more than a few cyber security whistleblowers in the future as more companies are hacked and faced with the question of disclosure.

The SEC also investigates violations of the rules by exchanges. They have sanctioned exchanges for failure to enforce Commission and exchange rules, inadequate investigation of compliance problems and unauthorized accommodations for member firms. When exchanges implement new businesses practices, or modify existing ones, without putting in place an exchange rule where one is required, they can also be subject to sanction.

The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act prohibits gifts and improper payments to foreign government officials to obtain or retain government contracts. A public company may be found to have violated the FCPA even if the conduct is done by certain third parties or through an intermediary. It also prohibits inaccurate books and records, as well as insufficient internal controls to detect corruption and prevent it from being included in financial statements. This has been the subject of several enforcement actions and SEC representatives believe it will be a fertile ground for whistleblowing.

Last Updated on: May 14th, 2018 at 4:16 pm, by

Written by admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *